Header
×
The Centre
Research
Training
Publications
The Centre
Research
Training
Publications

Family justice as care for relationships

More

Family justice as care for relationships

As part of the conference To each his own. The University Centres in dialogue on justice, held on 3 December 2024 at Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, the director of the University Centre for Family Studies and Research, Prof. Camillo Regalia, and Prof. Eugenia Scabini discussed the topic of justice from the point of view of family dynamics.

When we speak of justice we often say that it is actualized when each one is given his own, what is due to him – in the classical Thomist conception "reddere unicuique quod suum est". But how to decline this idea in a family perspective? To answer this question, it is necessary to remember what qualifies a person's identity. The identity of each person is built on the basis of the belongings from which he originates and in which he is inserted. These belongings have a deep family root, even if today this aspect is often denied or underestimated. This rootedness places each person within a long generational plot, which precedes us and at the same time represents the original foundation of each one.

In this perspective, giving each one his or her own is first and foremost the act of recognition of the position that each member of the family occupies in the fabric of generations, with the rights and duties linked to this position.

Secondly, if the person develops within the fabric of the family bonds that welcome him and that he builds over time, it is an expression of justice at the family level to give these bonds the care they need in order to flourish: in other words, everything that expresses a care for the other and of the bond is generative of justice, while they are forms of injustice that consume and disrupt relationships, every form of neglect or inadequate care.

Finally, the "his" that qualifies the dynamics of family justice is the logic of the gift, a quality of the family bond that has at its origin a gratuitous quid. When this element of gratuitousness is absent, we are faced with the injustice of those who are not only unable to give, but also use and exploit others. This gift, however, is not characterized by an absolute gratuitousness, that is, freed from the bond within which it is manifested. In fact, in relationships, the gift coexists with the other side of the coin, that is, debt and obligation. This means that the original gift and the grateful debt must be co-present, and it is in this circular dance between the movements of giving, receiving, reciprocating – movements plastically represented in the painting of Botticelli's Three Graces – that family justice is located. 

Family exchanges are also always subject to the risk of degeneration and disintegration: transgressions, offenses, physical and psychological violence are common experience in families. In these situations, family members are not only asked to resolve or settle a conflict. It is a question, in a more dramatic way, of being able to regain trust and hope in the family bond and achieve a pacification that allows a possible revival of the bond. To this end, the typically human and humanizing action of forgiving comes into play, that profound and mysterious gift that in its profound structure comes from the courage to recognize that people do not identify with the actions they commit and that the mistakes made by others are something not totally foreign to oneself. A forgiveness that is not only an inner movement of the soul, but an action aimed at establishing equity and relaunching the bond forward.  In this perspective, family justice detaches itself from a retributive vision of rights and wrongs, to highlight its potential liberating character. A forgiven relationship is a relationship that does not bind people forever to the third of the guilt, but frees people from the imprisonment of evil, which so effectively holds people together, both those who have offended and those who have been offended.

scroll-top-icon